Homeschoolers Should Participate in Public School Activities

The Florida law that granted Tebow, who was homeschooled, permission to participate in public school sports was passed in 1996.

Over the years, we have enjoyed the responsibility of teaching baseball to homeschooled students. I intended to write this week supporting homeschool participation in public school activities.

In that process, I asked one of our parents for some ideas. Here is what one parent, Eric Tibbets, told me: 

1. Purpose. 
   For us to participate in any activity, it has to have a purpose and mesh with
   our education goals.  To the degree sports can help with those goals, they
   are a good addition.  By no means is the sport an end unto itself, but an
   educational aid.  As an example, team sports teaches many favorable
   character attributes.  One is that the mission is far more important than
   the individual, a key life lesson.  My guess is that most homeschool
   parents will have goals for sports that are separate and distinct from the
   outcome of the contest and will not be the focus.  While Tim Tebow might
   be a good example of a homeschool student doing well in public school sports, a
   sports career is likely not the purpose for most parents.
2. Team vs. individual.  My guess is that team sports would be the focus of a
   homeschool family, for the most part.  If the goal is more about life
   lessons, team sports teaches those in ways individual sports cannot.
3. Authority.  It is important to me that my children are introduced to authority outside of me and my wife.  I say introduced because it is not surrendered by me until earned by the adult.  But familiarity with different 
   leadership/management styles is important.  We all know that it is the
   employee’s job to adapt to his boss and not the opposite, for example.  An
   early and frequent introduction to different authority styles is beneficial.
4. Coachability. I believe one of the greatest attributes any student can gain is the idea of being teachable or coachable.  Sports is a great training ground for the imperative of teachability. 
5. Leadership.  Team sports can teach important leadership traits including working with youth of all different skill levels, cultural, faith, political and family
   backgrounds.
6. Citizenship. Sports has a way of reflecting the greater society and the need to be a good citizen.  Doing our own part well and diligently along with teamwork are attributes that make not only good teammates but good citizens.
7. Exposure.  There is likelihood that many public-school students have not been exposed to homeschool students.  While this type of exposure is not a taxpayer
   burden, diversity is a two-way street.  To the degree homeschool students
   should socialize with other peer groups, public school students would benefit
   as well. 
8. Faith.  While is it not the public schools charter to develop students’ faith (a prime reason many choose homeschooling), it can be an ideal environment for one’s faith to be tested and stretched.  Whether public, private, or
   homeschooled, every person of faith will need to take ownership of his own
   faith, learn and tolerate the beliefs of others, navigate many diverse world
   views while standing on a firm foundation.  While not the taxpayers task
   to produce such results, understanding of other’s views and experiences is a
   benefit to our communities.

Many details remain to be announced.  Things like eligibility, districting, academic standing, age/grade consistencies. 

Another area is private schools and whether or not those students will have
access to public-school sports, regardless of whether the private school
provides that particular sports option.

Public school sports is not a “must have” for us nor for most homeschool families, I would submit.  It is merely an augment to a  well-rounded (mind-spirit-body) education. It should not be seen as a right but a privilege. 

Many taxpayers fund efforts they don’t use (empty-nesters, singles, childless families, private-school families, etc) and to argue that homeschool families deserve access as taxpayers does not have much relevance.

How do you feel about homeschoolers playing public school sports? Tell us in the comments.